10 Best Cat Toys of 2024, Rated and Reviewed

By: Stephanie BrownPublished:

a few of the best cat toys as tested by cat owners
Sara Paul

We’ve all been there. You buy your cat a nice, fancy toy, and then... you catch them playing with a random piece of plastic instead. Why bother at all?

There are many reasons to offer your cat a toy. And not just one, but a variety of toys.

Toys provide your cat with mental stimulation, physical exertion, and opportunities for bonding with you through playtime. Toys in your home actually create a more natural environment for your cat—similar to what they would experience in the wild.

“It's a much more natural lifestyle when they're engaging with toys and engaging with their environment,” says Sandra Mitchell, DVM, a traveling veterinarian and owner of All Creatures Veterinary Services based near Bangor, Maine. “Especially if you have the right toys that mimic the natural behaviors of cats—hunting, clawing things, stalking, food acquisition, and all those.”

So what are the right toys? There are teasers, puzzles, balls, and lasers, to name a few. How do you choose?

To help you find the best toys for your cat, we tested 31 of Chewy’s top-rated toys in real-world conditions. We rated each toy on the following attributes: engagement level, safety, design, and value.

The toys on this list are considered stimulating, safe (when used properly), well made with smart features, and all for a reasonable price.

What To Consider When Buying a Cat Toy

Potential for Engagement

Toys can help engage cats both mentally and physically. Whether your cat will find the toy stimulating will depend on how your cat likes to play.

Some cats like independent play. Mice, kickers, and plush toys are all things they can attack and play with on their own.

Some prefer moving toys, whether moved manually by you or automated. Things like wands, ball tracks, or lasers could suit such cats.

“It depends on the personality and some degree of trial and error,” Dr. Mitchell says.

Safety

The last thing any pet parent wants is for playtime to turn into a medical emergency. Dr. Mitchell says to be on the lookout for the following hazards:

  • Toys or pieces of a toy that are small enough to be swallowed. Those could cause choking or, if actually swallowed, an obstruction in the GI tract.
  • Anything that’s string-like. The string could become wrapped around a body part or swallowed and cause injury.

Such toys “should be for supervised play only or ‘no-no’ toys,” Dr. Mitchell says.

Design

Make sure the toy is designed to function the way you want your cat to play with it.

For example, if you want a ball toy that you can roll on the floor and have your cat chase it Tokyo-drift style, opt for one made from harder material, like rubber or plastic. Those are much more effective at rolling than a softer, plush-like ball, which is better for playing fetch, as your cat will be able to sink their teeth into it and carry it back to you.

If you plan to purchase a treat-dispensing toy, make sure the holes are big enough to allow the treat you intend to use to actually come out.

When picking a plush toy, ask yourself if you want it with or without a squeaker. Some plush toys also contain catnip to entice play. Could your cat use the extra incentives?

Aesthetics matter too. Because cat toys come in so many shapes, styles, and colors, it’s a great opportunity to show off your cat’s personality and yours. Or maybe you want something that blends in with your home’s decor. After all, it will likely be strewn about your home all day, every day.

Value

Prices vary across cat toys, and you want to make sure you’re getting your money’s worth. You can get little hunting/chasing toys, like balls and mice, for a few bucks. These types of toys tend to take a beating and can get lost easily. If they do start falling apart or go missing, it’s not a huge financial loss.

Puzzles and electronic toys, on the other hand, tend to cost more. With a higher price tag, it’s not uncommon to expect a higher level of craftsmanship and durability.

How We Tested

We started with 31 of Chewy’s best-selling cat toys that came highly rated by Chewy customers—the ones cat parents like you love the most.

Each toy was tested for at least one week. During the trial period, the pet parents were asked to initiate playtime daily with their cats and the toy, and the cats were free to play with the toys independently.

The pet parents then rated the toys on the above attributes. They also took notes on their experience and filled out a questionnaire.

Testers included:

  • Dr. Marci L. Koski, CFTBS, CFTPB: Koski is a certified feline behavior and training consultant at Feline Behavior Solutions in Vancouver, Washington. She tested cat toys with her domestic shorthair cats, Samantha, 16; Momo, 15; and Oliver, 15.
Tester's 3 cats playing with best puzzle toy

The Buggin’ Out cat puzzle toy is large enough for Samantha, Momo, and Oliver to play all at once. Photo courtesy of Marci Koski.

  • LeeAnna Buis, CFTBS, FFCP: Buis is a certified feline behavior and training consultant at Feline Behavior Solutions in the Seattle area. She tested cat toys with her cat 6-year-old black cat, Ollie.
Tester cat Ollie plays with the best cat plush toy, a squirrel plush from Frisco.

Ollie gets up close and personal with the Frisco Squirrel plush toy. Photo courtesy of LeeAnna Buis.

  • Casey Seleman: Seleman is a veterinary technician at Woodstock Animal Hospital in Woodstock, New York. She tested cat toys with her 9-year-old cat, Serendipity, or Dip for short.
Kitty tester Dip chases after the SmartyKat® Instincts Hidden Hijinks Electronic Cat Toy

Dip chases after the SmartyKat Instincts Hidden Hijinks Electronic Cat Toy. Photo courtesy of Casey Seleman.

  • Claudia Guthrie: Guthrie is a Chewy editor who has written and edited cat health and behavior articles for four years. She tested cat toys with her cats John Wick, 5, and Winnie, 7.
Kitty tester John Wick poses with the best cat ball toys from SunGrow

John Wick poses with this new favorite cat ball toys from SunGrow. Photo courtesy of Claudia Guthrie.

  • Stephanie Brown: Brown is a Chewy editor who has been writing and editing content on a wide array of cat topics for over 10 years. She tested cat toys with her 7-year-old sassy tortie, Luna.
Luna the cat plays with the best ball track toy.

Luna keeps her eye on the ball inside the Frisco Scratch & Roll cat toy. Photo courtesy of Stephanie Brown.

Buying Guide: Types of Cat Toys

Interactive Cat Toys

Dr. Mitchell defines these toys as those that require interaction between the human, the toy, and the cat. Examples include wand toys and laser pointers (more on both of those below).

“You’re on one end of the teaser wand and the cat on the other end with the toy in the middle, as opposed to those little mice you can sit on the ground and the cat chases the mice, and you’re not involved anymore,” she says.

Teaser Toys/Wands

These are long wands with a dangly object of some sort on the end. The object is typically a plush toy, feathers, or a ribbon. As an interactive toy, they require pet parent interaction, specifically waving it around for the cat to catch.

Dr. Mitchell advises pet parents to exercise caution when playing with these toys, and to only let cats play with them under supervision. The strings could become twisted around limbs, or the toy can get caught in their teeth. If you play too rough, especially after they’ve caught it, you could inadvertently cause an injury.

“It’s not a dog tug-of-war toy. It’s not meant to be ripped out of their mouths,” she says.

Play with it until the cat catches it, then let the cat have it.

“The idea is to mimic a bird that’s flying, and then as soon as the cat catches it, the bird drops dead,” she says. “It’s not meant for you to continue fighting it, like you’ve got a fish on the end of the line.”

Cat Laser Toys

Many cats love to chase the little red dot of a laser pointer. Some are the traditional laser pointer styles, like the Litterbox.com laser we’re recommending, and some are automated, moving on their own.

The key to having your cat play with laser pointer is to not overdo it and to mimic the actions a cat takes when hunting.

“Leave it very still for a while and let the cat kind of beat in on it, then make it run across the floor,” Dr. Mitchell explains.

And always let them “catch” it occasionally.

“If [the cat] never catches it, then what’s the point of the game?” she says.

Never shine it directly into their eyes.

Cat Ball Toys

Ball toys come in a variety of materials and textures. They can be crinkly or made of hard plastic, maybe with bells in them, or soft and plush. Some even have feathers on them.

Dr. Mitchell categorizes these into two main types:

  1. More solid balls, which easily roll across the floor and are good for swatting
  2. Balls made of a softer material, which are better for playing fetch because they’re easier to carry

“I find that the cats that like the ping-pong ball types aren’t necessarily fetchers and vice versa, so it takes trying a few different ball styles to figure it out,” she says.

Cat Plush Toys

Plush toys for cats come in all shapes and sizes, from mice and other wild animals to bananas and ice cream cones.

Cats may cuddle against these or drag them around the house. If the stuffed toy is small enough, you could toss it and use it for playing fetch. They also make great toys to wrestle with.

Dr. Mitchells says the ones that are infused with catnip or that crinkle are probably more likely to excite your cat—and take the brunt of bunny kicks.

In fact, there are specific types of plush toys that a meant to be kicked. These so-called kicker toys are designed so cats can grab onto them with their front paws and “bunny kick” them with their hind legs.

Cat Puzzle Toys

Puzzles toys usually require the cat to move the toy or parts of the toy around to reveal a treat.

These can be board games where cats have to slide or otherwise move game pieces to uncover the treats. These can also be treat-dispensing toys, like a ball that you fill with treats or kibble, and the cat has to roll the ball around to get a treat to come out.

Puzzle toys engage cat’s hunting instincts while also engaging their mind by having them solve the problem at hand: How do I get this food?

“In the wild, they have to figure out how to get their food every day,” Dr. Mitchell says. “Again, it mimics a more natural behavior.”

Another benefit of a puzzle toy is that it helps the cat burn calories, especially if they’re chasing down a treat-dispensing toy.

“I think it’s a win/win all the way around,” says Dr. Mitchell.

Cat Chew Toys

Cat chew toys are either stuffed toys, usually with a mesh overlay, or rubber toys that cats can chew on. They’re typically marketed as promoting dental health by helping to keep cat’s teeth clean.

Dr. Mitchell says to be cautious of any items that could become loose during chewing and present a choking hazard.

“If they’re chewing on something that’s got netting or something that’s rubber, we always worry about foreign body ingestion,” she says.

Electronic Toys

Electronic toys are toys that move with help from a power source, like batteries. Some are rechargeable with a USB charger. When turned on, they run for a pre-determined period of time; others are motion-sensor activated and only start when moved by you or the cat.

These types of self-play toys help engage your cat in playtime, and are good ways to keep your cat busy when you’re away from home.

Just make sure your cat is comfortable with the automation, Dr. Mitchell says. You don’t want them to get spooked by the sudden movement and end up being afraid of the toy.

Ball Track Toys

These are another form of self-play toys where a ball is locked into a track, like a ring or a little race car-type track, and the cat can push the ball along with their paws. They’re another great toy to help keep your cat busy when you can’t be there to play with them.

Cat Toy FAQs

Q: What toys do cats like the most?
A: The best cat toy depends on your cat and their personal preference.

Some cats may prefer independent play, which typically includes plush toys, kicker toys, balls and ball track toys, tunnels, puzzles, and electronic toys. Others may prefer to interact with you when playing. Toys that encourage this type of interactive playtime include wands, lasers, and balls or push toys for a game of fetch.

You may notice that some toys can be used for both types of play. Finding the best toy for your cat and how to play with said toy will require some trial and error.

Q: Should you have multiple types of toys for your cat?
A: Yes, you should offer your cat a variety of toys. You never know what style of play is going to strike a cat’s fancy on any given day. Having different types of toys allows them to engage in a variety of play styles.

Even having multiple of the same type of toy is beneficial because you can rotate them, ensuring there is always something “new” that you can swap in to pique their interest.

“The more the merrier,” Dr. Mitchell says.

Q: How can I keep my cat entertained?
A: In addition to cat toys, clicker training, providing access to windows that your cat can look out of (a window perch could help here), and playing cat-approved nature shows or music are all ways to keep your cat entertained.

Looking for even more cat toys? If you’re a Swiftie, you’ll love these cats toys and other cat products that match every Taylor Swift Era.